"We're trying to re-envision Laguna Hills," Mayor Don Caskey told the Orange County Register in July. "68 acres gives us the opportunity to make a really big, positive point on that." The Laguna Hills Mall closed eight years ago, and its building was razed in 2023. Merlone Geier Partners has owned the property since 2013. The Register calls the property vacant. That's true of the middle, but the edges of the lot never closed, and the plan the city approved this summer is laid out around them.
Two Votes, Six Weeks Apart
The revised Village at Laguna Hills went through City Hall in two steps this summer:
- July 14, 2026. The City Council and Planning Agency approved the project's modified entitlements by a 3–2 vote. These included a site development permit, the permit for an additional hotel, an amended tract map that divides 10 existing lots into 27, and a restated development agreement. Councilmembers Erica Pezold and Dave Wheeler voted no. According to the Register, both wanted more time to review the changes and the new documents. The meeting record lists 35 written comments in favor and 13 opposed.
- August 25, 2026. The council adopted the Urban Village Specific Plan amendment 4–1, with Pezold the only no vote. When the development agreement came up, the minutes record 22 written comments in support, a no vote from Pezold, and Wheeler declining to vote.
Several speakers at the July hearing asked for the affordable housing to serve a wider range of people, especially people who work in Laguna Hills. Caskey answered that the city would push for broader access in the future, but that the developer will ultimately decide who the affordable units are for.
What Got Cut, and What Replaced It
The 2022 approval pictured a denser, office-heavy center. The 2026 version trades the office space and the cinema for homes and hotel rooms.
| Element | 2022 approved plan | 2026 revised plan |
|---|---|---|
| Office | 465,000 sq ft | Removed |
| Retail | 250,000 sq ft | About 163,000 sq ft |
| Hotel | One five-story hotel, 100 to 150 rooms | Two four-story hotels, 239 rooms combined |
| Movie theater and gym | Included | Removed |
| Homes | Up to 1,500 units | 1,457 units, including at least 200 affordable units for seniors |
| Daily traffic trips | Baseline | About 25% fewer, per the developer |
The new plan builds the senior affordable units in one dedicated building of at least 200 units on a pad handed to an affordable housing developer, instead of spreading them across several buildings over time. The remaining units are a mix of apartments, townhomes, duplexes and single-family detached homes. City staff gave economic feasibility as the main reason for dropping the gym and theater.
Even with less retail, city officials expect the project to bring in more money than the version it replaces. They project an annual general fund surplus of about $2 million and almost $29 million in developer fees, and more than $20 million of that is earmarked for parks and recreation. Councilmember Jared Mathis said the revenue would be "more than the mall," even adjusted for inflation, at its peak.
The Park Moved to Face El Toro Road
Dropping the cinema changed more than the square footage. In the developer's words, the theater had been "driving the energy" around the planned gathering space, so the space was moved. The new Village Park will be visible from El Toro Road and sit next to the medical center. The Register describes it as an enhanced 3-acre community park with neighborhood-oriented retail, restaurants and walking paths built around it.
The buildings will be Spanish Colonial Revival throughout, a style chosen to match City Hall across the street at the El Toro intersection. In practice, the redesign turns the project toward the existing civic corner. Under the old plan, the social center was a second-story cinema inside the site. Under the new one, it's a park you can see from one of the city's busiest roads, across from the city's own building.
The Parts of the Site That Never Closed
Three restaurants on the property are expected to stay through the redevelopment: BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse, King's Fish House and In-N-Out Burger. King's Fish House and In-N-Out still list the Laguna Hills Mall address with regular daily hours. Nordstrom Rack is open at 23541 Calle de la Louisa.
Nordstrom Rack is also one of two anchor names in the city's July 10, 2026 fiscal analysis. That study modeled anchor spaces under the names Nordstrom Rack and Whole Foods, along with 163,215 square feet of nonresidential space and 239 hotel rooms. The analysis presents those names as inputs to a revenue model. Among the restaurants and stores staying on site, the Register's July story names only BJ's, King's Fish House and In-N-Out. On paper, then, one of the two anchors in the city's model is a store already open next to the site.
Approval Is Not a Groundbreaking
Getting through the council clears the zoning. It doesn't put equipment on the lot. In May, the developer's FAQ estimated that after council approval, the project would need another 6 to 12 months to get site development and building permits before the first construction phases could begin. That estimate was written before the votes, and no updated construction schedule has been published since. Caskey has said the developer expects to finish the project in three tentative phases over roughly the next decade. City officials also say they have no specific plans yet for development next to the site, though they hope the Village will encourage some.
The developer has said that more details on timing, rents and waitlists for the senior affordable building will go out to its email list once the modified plan is approved and it is able to move forward with that building. For now, the lot looks the way it has since 2023, with working businesses around the edges and open ground in the middle.
October on the Edges of the Lot
This month, the most visible thing happening on the property is a seasonal one. Pumpkin City is back at 24203 Avenida de la Carlota, behind Trader Joe's, from October 1 through 31. It has rides, games, food, daily entertainment, an Oktoberfest beer garden and free parking. The pumpkin farm describes its location as Laguna Hills Mall, a name the property has kept through eight years without a mall.
Other October dates around town:
- Wednesday, October 7, 5:30 to 8 p.m. Bingo Night at Polly's Pies, on the Laguna Hills Chamber of Commerce calendar.
- Saturday, October 10, 4 to 7 p.m. Harvest in the Hills on the Town Green at the Laguna Hills Community Center, 25555 Alicia Parkway.
- Saturday, October 31, 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. A "Spook-Tacular" on the Chamber calendar. The listing doesn't give a venue yet, so check before you go.
Until permits are issued, the Village at Laguna Hills consists of the BJ's, King's Fish House and In-N-Out still serving on the property, the Nordstrom Rack on Calle de la Louisa, and a pumpkin patch behind Trader Joe's that closes on Halloween.
A decade-long, three-phase project next to your street raises real questions about the homes nearby, and the answers depend on details. If you own near the El Toro and Avenida de la Carlota corridor and want a calm, well-informed read on what the approved plan means for your property, Laura Ginn can start with a private home value review.